GeometricPish wrote:Just a couple of thoughts on this video, is it possible that the recording may come from the Lighthouse gig? As far as I can tell, both live versions are identical to the soundboard recording, so why is it assumed it's the ATP version? Is it because the ATP film used a supposed soundboard version of Echus?
There's even a possibility that this version of Julie and Candy isn't even a soundboard recording at all, instead it may just be unheard studio version. I'm sure many musicians record alternative takes/mixes for a lot of their music. More than likely it is just a soundboard recording, but I just thought I'd throw this suggestion out there as a possibility.
Finally, when the voice comes in at around 42 seconds, it sounds to me like a muffled version of the guy saying 'number nine' in The Beatles' Revolution 9. Anyone else hear that?
You're right it pretty much is identical to the Lighthouse show version as well. When I made this thread I think it was before I had even heard the Lighthouse show, so that's mostly the only reason.
Also, you could be right about the number nine voice sample, I can definitely hear that. I had always just thought it was a sample of.....how do I describe it....like the noise a rope might make if you pull it through some kind of hole....like what's at the very end of this track
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVWEqQnjT0M